The concept of the “illusion of inclusion” describes the practice of appearing inclusive while maintaining systems and structures that continue to marginalize. Unfortunately, the recent actions by the Manitoba government regarding support for Black entrepreneurs exemplify this concern.

On February 6, 2025, during Black History Month, the Government of Manitoba announced a $200,000 pilot program to support Black entrepreneurs and business owners. Minister Moses stated that the funds would be administered by the Manitoba Chamber of Commerce, an organization with no specific mandate to serve Black communities, rather than the Black Manitobans Chamber of Commerce (BMCC), an established entity dedicated to this very work since 2022.

This decision is both disappointing and disheartening.

BMCC was launched in the presence of Premier Wab Kinew, Minister Moses, and other officials who publicly affirmed their commitment to supporting Black entrepreneurs. Now, with the power of office, the government’s actions speak louder than past promises. We are left questioning: would this approach have been taken if the funding was intended for Indigenous businesses? Would their leadership have been bypassed in favor of symbolic inclusion?

The Minister approached BMCC just before the announcement was made, inviting us to participate in a photo opportunity after the program and committee were already finalized without any meaningful consultation. We declined to participate in what we viewed as a superficial gesture that failed to reflect genuine collaboration.

More recently, BMCC was contacted again and encouraged to apply for a $5,000 grant as part of this program. While we appreciate the gesture, we respectfully decline. We do not accept tokenism or performative inclusion.

We categorically denounce this process as an example of the illusion of support for the Black business community. It is not only condescending to suggest that $200,000 is a substantial investment for 2.3% of Manitoba’s businesses, but it is also disrespectful to overlook BMCC in favor of a body that does not represent or understand the lived realities of Black entrepreneurs in this province.

The BMCC calls on the Government of Manitoba to take immediate corrective action. We urge a transparent and respectful dialogue centered on meaningful collaboration. We expect a process that recognizes our autonomy, our expertise, and our capacity to serve our community without being sidelined or supervised.

Only through authentic engagement and equitable practices can we build a Manitoba that truly reflects its commitment to inclusion, diversity, and reconciliation not just in word, but in deed.

Sincerely,

Black Manitobans Chamber of Commerce